What is the Icing on Cookies Called? Unveiling the Sweet Truth

The delightful sweetness that adorns cookies, transforming them from simple baked goods into miniature works of art, goes by a few names. While technically it’s all “icing,” the specific term used often depends on the consistency, application, and intended purpose of that sugary coating. Let’s dive into the world of cookie coverings and explore the nuances of what we call the icing on cookies.

Table of Contents

Exploring the Different Types of Cookie Icing

It’s easy to assume that all cookie icing is created equal, but that’s far from the truth. The world of cookie decoration is surprisingly diverse, with each type of icing offering unique properties and applications. Knowing the distinctions can help you choose the right icing for your baking project and understand the subtle vocabulary used by bakers and decorators.

Royal Icing: The King of Cookie Decoration

Royal icing reigns supreme when it comes to detailed cookie decorating. It’s a smooth, hard-drying icing made primarily from powdered sugar, egg whites (or meringue powder), and water. The consistency can be adjusted, making it incredibly versatile.

The Role of Egg Whites (or Meringue Powder): Egg whites, traditionally used, provide the structural integrity of royal icing. Meringue powder, a dried egg white substitute, is often preferred for its convenience and safety, especially in environments where raw egg consumption is a concern. It also helps to create a more stable and predictable icing.
Achieving the Right Consistency: Royal icing comes in different consistencies, categorized as “flood consistency” and “piping consistency.” Flood consistency is thinner, used to fill in large areas smoothly. Piping consistency is thicker, perfect for outlining, adding details, and creating intricate designs. Achieving the right consistency is crucial for achieving professional-looking results.
Drying Time and Storage: Royal icing needs time to dry completely, typically several hours or even overnight, depending on humidity and thickness. Once dried, it forms a hard, smooth surface that’s relatively durable. It can be stored in an airtight container at room temperature for a few weeks, or in the refrigerator for longer periods.
Coloring Royal Icing: Gel food coloring is the preferred method for coloring royal icing. Liquid food coloring can alter the consistency, making it too thin. A small amount of gel coloring goes a long way, allowing you to achieve vibrant and consistent colors.

Glaze: The Simple, Shiny Finish

Glaze is a simpler form of cookie icing, typically made from powdered sugar and a liquid, such as milk, water, or lemon juice. It’s thinner than royal icing and creates a smooth, shiny finish.

The Essence of Simplicity: Glaze is incredibly easy to make, requiring just two basic ingredients: powdered sugar and a liquid. This simplicity makes it a great choice for quick and easy cookie decoration.
Achieving the Desired Shine: The type of liquid used can influence the final appearance of the glaze. Milk creates a slightly opaque finish, while lemon juice adds a subtle tartness and enhances the shine.
Ideal for Drizzling and Dipping: Glaze is perfect for drizzling over cookies or dipping the tops of cookies for a uniform coating. It’s a great option for adding a touch of sweetness and visual appeal without requiring intricate decorating skills.
Drying Time and Texture: Glaze dries relatively quickly, usually within an hour or two. It doesn’t harden as much as royal icing, resulting in a softer, slightly sticky texture.

Frosting: The Creamy Delight

While frosting is more commonly associated with cakes, it can also be used on cookies, especially soft cookies or sugar cookies where a softer texture is desired. Frosting is typically made with butter, powdered sugar, and a liquid, resulting in a creamy and richer consistency than royal icing or glaze.

Buttercream Variations: There are many types of buttercream frosting, including American buttercream, Swiss meringue buttercream, and Italian meringue buttercream. Each type offers a different texture and level of sweetness. American buttercream is the simplest and sweetest, while Swiss and Italian meringue buttercreams are smoother and less sweet.
A Softer Touch: Frosting remains soft and creamy, even after it sets. This makes it ideal for cookies that are intended to be eaten soon after decoration.
Piping and Spreading: Frosting can be piped onto cookies using various decorating tips, or it can be spread on with a knife or spatula. It’s less precise than royal icing for intricate designs, but it’s great for creating swirls, rosettes, and other simple decorations.
Refrigeration Requirements: Due to its butter content, frosting is best stored in the refrigerator. Cookies decorated with frosting should also be refrigerated to prevent the frosting from melting or spoiling.

Fondant: The Smooth, Sculptable Covering

While less common for everyday cookies, fondant is sometimes used for special occasion cookies that require a very smooth, flawless finish or for creating three-dimensional decorations. Fondant is a sugar paste that can be rolled out and draped over cookies, creating a smooth canvas for further decoration.

The Art of Smoothness: Fondant creates an incredibly smooth and professional-looking finish. It’s often used for cookies that are meant to resemble miniature cakes.
Sculpting Possibilities: Fondant can be molded and sculpted into various shapes, allowing for the creation of intricate decorations and embellishments.
A Unique Texture: Fondant has a slightly chewy texture that is different from royal icing, glaze, or frosting. Some people enjoy this texture, while others find it less appealing.
Adhering Fondant to Cookies: To adhere fondant to cookies, a thin layer of buttercream or royal icing is typically used as “glue.” This helps the fondant stick to the cookie and prevents it from drying out.

The Baker’s Vocabulary: Deciphering the Icing Terminology

Understanding the different types of icing is only part of the equation. Bakers and cookie decorators often use specific terms to describe the characteristics and application of icing. Being familiar with these terms will help you communicate effectively with other bakers and understand recipes and tutorials more easily.

Flood Consistency: As mentioned earlier, this refers to a thin, pourable royal icing that is used to fill in large areas of a cookie smoothly. It should be thin enough to spread easily but thick enough to hold its shape and not run off the edges of the cookie.
Piping Consistency: This is a thicker royal icing that is used for outlining, adding details, and creating intricate designs. It should be thick enough to hold its shape when piped but thin enough to flow smoothly through a piping bag.
Wet-on-Wet Technique: This decorating technique involves applying different colors of flood consistency icing to a cookie while the base icing is still wet. This allows the colors to blend and create beautiful marbled or swirled effects.
Stiff Peaks: This term, often used in frosting recipes, refers to the consistency of the frosting when it’s whipped. Stiff peaks indicate that the frosting is stable enough to hold its shape and is suitable for piping.
Crusting: This refers to the process of royal icing hardening on the surface. A crusting icing is essential for creating layered decorations and preventing colors from bleeding together.

Choosing the Right Icing for Your Cookies

The best type of icing for your cookies depends on several factors, including the type of cookie, the desired appearance, and your decorating skills.

Icing Type	Consistency	Best For	Pros	Cons
Royal Icing	Varies (Flood & Piping)	Detailed decorating, intricate designs	Versatile, durable, dries hard, excellent for detail	Requires practice, longer drying time
Glaze	Thin, pourable	Simple decorating, drizzling, dipping	Easy to make, quick drying, shiny finish	Less precise, softer texture
Frosting	Creamy, soft	Soft cookies, simple decorations, spreading	Rich flavor, creamy texture, easy to spread	Requires refrigeration, less precise for detail
Fondant	Smooth, rollable	Flawless finish, sculpting, 3D decorations	Very smooth, professional look, sculptable	Unique texture, requires buttercream or royal icing “glue”

For Intricate Designs: If you’re aiming for elaborate designs and detailed patterns, royal icing is the clear winner. Its versatility and ability to dry hard make it ideal for creating miniature works of art.
For Simplicity and Speed: If you’re short on time or prefer a more rustic look, glaze is a great option. It’s quick to make and easy to apply, adding a touch of sweetness and shine with minimal effort.
For a Creamy Texture: If you want a softer, richer flavor, frosting is the way to go. It’s perfect for cookies that are meant to be eaten soon after decoration and provides a delightful creamy texture.
For a Flawless Finish: If you’re looking for a super-smooth, professional finish, fondant is the best choice. It creates a polished look and allows for endless possibilities in terms of sculpting and decorating.

Ultimately, the choice is yours. Experiment with different types of icing and find what works best for your style and skill level. And remember, the most important ingredient is always love (and maybe a little bit of sugar!).

Beyond the Basics: Icing Techniques and Tips

Once you’ve chosen your icing, it’s time to put it to use. Here are a few tips and techniques to help you achieve professional-looking results.

Practice Makes Perfect: Decorating cookies with royal icing takes practice. Start with simple designs and gradually work your way up to more complex patterns.
Use a Piping Bag and Tips: Piping bags and decorating tips are essential tools for creating precise designs with royal icing and frosting. Experiment with different tips to achieve various effects.
Outline First, Then Fill: When using royal icing, it’s best to outline the cookie with piping consistency icing and then fill in the center with flood consistency icing. This helps to create a clean and defined edge.
Use a Scribe Tool or Toothpick: A scribe tool or toothpick can be used to smooth out the flood consistency icing and pop any air bubbles.
Let the Icing Dry Completely: Be patient and allow the icing to dry completely before adding any additional decorations or packaging the cookies. This will prevent smudging and ensure that your designs stay intact.

The Final Sweet Thought

So, what is the icing on cookies called? The answer, as we’ve seen, is multifaceted. It depends on the specific type of icing and its intended use. Whether it’s royal icing, glaze, frosting, or fondant, the sweet coating on cookies is what transforms them into delightful treats that bring joy to everyone who enjoys them. Mastering the art of cookie decorating is a journey, but with a little practice and the right knowledge, you can create stunning and delicious cookies that are sure to impress.

Enjoy the sweet adventure!

What is the most common term for the icing used on cookies?

The most common term for the icing used on cookies is generally “cookie icing.” This is a broad and readily understood term that encompasses various types of icing suitable for decorating cookies. While there are more specific names for different icing consistencies and ingredients, “cookie icing” serves as a universal and widely accepted descriptor.

In the culinary world, you might also hear terms like “royal icing,” “glaze,” or “frosting” being used, depending on the specific recipe and desired effect. However, for everyday language and general understanding, “cookie icing” remains the most frequently used and recognized term when referring to the sugary coating applied to cookies.

Is there a difference between cookie icing and frosting?

Yes, there is a subtle but important difference between cookie icing and frosting. Frosting is typically thicker and creamier, often used to cover cakes or cupcakes. It’s designed to be more substantial and hold its shape well, offering a richer flavor and texture.

Cookie icing, on the other hand, is generally thinner and less dense than frosting. It’s designed to spread easily and create a smooth, glossy finish on cookies. While frosting aims for height and decorative volume, cookie icing focuses on providing a thin, even layer of sweetness and design details.

What is royal icing and how does it differ from other cookie icings?

Royal icing is a specific type of cookie icing made primarily from powdered sugar, meringue powder (or egg whites), and water. It’s known for its ability to dry hard and smooth, making it ideal for intricate designs and decorations on cookies that need to hold their shape. The addition of meringue powder provides stability and prevents the icing from becoming too runny.

Unlike other cookie icings, such as simple glazes or buttercreams, royal icing dries to a firm, almost porcelain-like finish. This allows for the creation of delicate details, intricate patterns, and even 3D elements on cookies. Its durability makes it a popular choice for cookies that need to be packaged and transported.

What are some common ingredients in cookie icing besides powdered sugar?

Besides powdered sugar, which is the base of most cookie icings, several other ingredients are commonly used to achieve different flavors, textures, and consistencies. These include liquids like water, milk, or lemon juice, which help to thin the icing and create a smooth spreadable consistency.

Other frequently used ingredients are corn syrup for added shine and flexibility, extracts like vanilla or almond for flavoring, and food coloring for creating vibrant and eye-catching designs. Depending on the desired result, some recipes might also incorporate butter, cream cheese, or even egg whites to alter the richness and texture of the icing.

How do you achieve different consistencies of cookie icing?

Achieving different consistencies of cookie icing primarily involves adjusting the amount of liquid added to the base ingredients. A thicker consistency, ideal for outlining cookies or creating detailed designs, is achieved by using less liquid and a higher ratio of powdered sugar.

For a thinner, flood-like consistency perfect for filling in larger areas of the cookie, you simply add more liquid until the icing reaches a smooth, easily spreadable consistency. The “10-second rule” is a common guideline: when a line is drawn in the icing, it should disappear back into the surrounding icing within 10 seconds for a good flooding consistency.

Can you store leftover cookie icing?

Yes, you can definitely store leftover cookie icing. The key is to prevent it from drying out. For royal icing, store it in an airtight container with a piece of plastic wrap pressed directly onto the surface of the icing to prevent a crust from forming. This will help maintain its consistency and prevent it from hardening.

For other types of cookie icing, such as glazes or buttercreams, the same principle applies. An airtight container is essential, and refrigeration is generally recommended, especially if the icing contains dairy products. Be sure to allow the icing to come to room temperature and remix it well before using it again, as it may separate slightly during storage.

Is cookie icing gluten-free?

In most cases, cookie icing is naturally gluten-free. The primary ingredients, such as powdered sugar, liquids, and flavor extracts, do not typically contain gluten. However, it is always crucial to check the ingredient labels of all components used to ensure they are certified gluten-free, especially if you are making icing for someone with celiac disease or gluten intolerance.

Specifically, be mindful of flavor extracts, as some might contain trace amounts of gluten due to processing methods. Also, be careful about cross-contamination in your kitchen. Ensure that utensils and mixing bowls used for making gluten-free icing haven’t previously been used for gluten-containing products. If you use meringue powder, confirm it is gluten-free as well.